New AdWords matching option discovered – ‘the bogus broad match type’

October 21st, 2007 by admin

Most PPC enthusiasts will be aware of the four common AdWords matching types:

  • Broad
  • Phrase
  • Exact
  • Negative (can be broad, phrase or exact)

Here is a quick overview of what keyword matching is all about, for the non PPC folks:

Keyword matching allows you to control how precise a user’s search must be to trigger your ad on Google search pages. Defining how broadly or narrowly your keywords are targeted helps you reach the audience you want. Source AdWords Learning Center

However based on AdWords definition of match types, I think I have found a new one and I am naming it the 'bogus broad match'.

So what is the bogus broad match type?

Good question, it seems to be a hybrid of the broad match type and the ability to bid on partially related keywords. How and when it evolved I am uncertain, although I am pretty sure of its existence.

Let's look at the characteristics of a broad match first:

  • Other words are included in the query
  • Terms in the query are not written in the same sequence as your keyword
  • The query is similar to your keyword. This includes plurals and synonyms.
  • All the terms must be present

The bogus broad match takes all the above characteristics except for the last one "“ not all the terms have to be present.

By this I have had an experience of bidding on a two worded keyphrase and the ad showing for only a one worded search term.

An example of this would be to bid on the keyword phrase 'bank holiday' on broad match and for your ad to be shown for the search term 'holiday'. This would result in unqualified paid traffic landing on your site, eeek!

You may wander how I discovered what the actual search term was "“ this was not through a third-party analytics package, it was though AdWords very own Search Query Report.

This is difficult to prove without providing login details, and I am curious to see if anyone else has experienced a sighting of the bogus broad match type.

How to overcome the bogus broad match type?

If you believe in that the bb match type existing there is a way to overcome it and it involves the lesser known negative embedded match type. This did the trick for me, but seems a little unnecessary:

e.g.
Bank holiday
"“[holiday]

You may have to include embedded negative plurals and synonyms "“ although I have not had a problem with this.

It is always good practice to run search query report every now and then as part of campaign optimisation and if you do, you may encounter the bogus broad match – be warned! Of course, it could be a blip in the search query reporting or perhaps even a blip in my reporting – although I would like to say the latter is unlikely to be true as I have experienced it several times in the last couple of months. Anyone else seen the same?

AdWords Campaign Optimizer – Optimization or Google Monetization?

October 9th, 2007 by admin

I'LL LET YOU BE THE JUDGE!
Last week I spent sometime checking out the AdWords Campaign Optimizer and was left a little ruffled as to whether it was a useful optimisation tool or another way for Google to monetize on advertisers spend. It's been around for a couple of months, so let's have a quick look at what it does:
Google blurb:

  1. "It’s an on-demand AdWords tool that provides personalized campaign ideas in just minutes"
  2. "Since Campaign Optimizer is an automated tool, we suggest that it be the first stepnot the last – in optimizing your account."

And here's what Google says it can be used for:

  1. Change daily budget. Budget adjustments can affect your ad visibility and bring you more traffic.
  2. Add new keywords. Campaign Optimizer proposes targeted keywords that relate to your landing page.
  3. Change keyword matching options. The right matching option can help you reach customers more effectively.
  4. Adjust keyword maximum cost-per-click bid. Your maximum CPC bid (in addition to your ad quality) affects your ad position.
  5. Change ad text. Your ad text affects your click-through rate.

Google covers itself several times by stating that it's an automated tool and should only be used as the first steps of optimisation.

There are hints of useful optimisation tips for the novice AdWords user, although Google seems to have a very clear and loud optimized call to action of its own – "spend more money" and perhaps Campaign Monetizer would be a more fitting name? Not sure why I think this? Re-read the above bulleting points!

Unfortunately the monetization is geared towards Google's ever expanding pockets, rather than the average and often lonely AdWords advertiser. Those that have an understanding for AdWords are unlikely to find the basic suggestions of any use and those that don't are encouraged to spend more money with a lack of any real PPC optimization.

To justify the tools name it would have been nice to see it better integrated with the existing AdWords' conversion tracking. Albeit Google does state that the Campain Monitizer Campaign Optimizer should be the first and not last step in optimization, and although it does indeed make sense, I am still left questioning who will find the tool useful or benefit from it? The AdWords newbie, the intermediate PPC chappy, the seasoned veteran or perhaps Google itself? Me thinks the latter!

Am I being a too cynical? Are Google finally feeling the pinch and responding with subtle money spinners for a quick win? I will let you be the judge of this, although you may want to checkout the AdWords Top Ad Placement formulae post over at PPC Blog if you are still insure :) !

Search Marketing Standard Fall Magazine

September 11th, 2007 by admin

soldier

As Jim Morison once drunkenly sang 'Summer's almost gone' and to confirm just that came the arrival of the Search Marketing Standard's Fall Magazine onto my doorstep. Nevertheless it is was packed full semy goodness and here's a quick overview as to what stood out for me:

Article 1) Search Engine Market Share "“ Google Still Stands Tall in the UK

Tall as in super-size tall, with a whooping 79.38% of the market share and leaving Yahoo in its shadows in second place at 7.72%. That makes Google nearly 10 times more popular than Yahoo and MSN trails in third at 5.28%, with Ask and all its offline marketing (UK) just behind in fourth with 4.87%

This is not really surprising, although I think it really does depend on the industry that you are in and the type of product or services that you offer. It is not unusual for Yahoo to be closer to 30 – 40% for certain queries or fewer than 1% for more technical ones, so it’s good to be aware!

Article 2) What do SEM Professionals keep in their Toolkits?

The 'What do busy SEM Professionals keep in their Toolkits' article is a pretty handy one, with lots cool SEM tools and the two that I found both new and useful "“ courtesy of Andy Beal are:

Article 3) Integrating SMM into SEM

Yes Cameron Olthuis has produced another great piece which is all about integrating your every day search engine marketing efforts into social media marketing.

For those new to SMM, you may want to checkout the social media marketing post I knocked up late last year. Essentially Cameron breaks down SMM into two distinct entities, linkbaiting and reputation management.

The Search Marketing Standard Magazine is a worthy read for any search marketer and if you are interested in subscribing, shoot over to their blog.

AdWords Quality Score - are your keyword soldiers solo or team players?

September 2nd, 2007 by admin

soldierIt's been quite a debate for a while now – should you consider keywords as separate entities with regards to quality score?

Do keywords with a low quality score create a bad neighbourhood for all others?

Should you ditch lower performing keywords? And are your keywords solo or team soldiers?

Well it appears that keywords are team players, they do influence each others quality score and you should consider dumping keywords with a low quality score as they can have a negative effect within the ‘hood!

How do I know?
"“ well a combination of first hand experience, talking to Google and through fellow SEM pros.

Ask Google

During a recent visit to Google London, I asked these very questions and the answer I received was pretty straightforward and went something like this:

AdWords quality score is housed at an account level, with keyword quality scores having an accumulative affect on the overall account quality score. And the account quality score also has an impact on a keyword’s quality score.

What can we learn from this? Well it is safe to say that keywords with a lower quality score can have a negative influence on neighbouring keywords and that they aren’t solo soldiers "“ they are team players and if one gets hit by a low quality score then they all feel the pain to a certain extent.

First hand experience

Over the last year I have seen patterns to suggest that an account with a good account quality score, receives favourable quality scores for newly added keywords.

An example of this would be an advertiser that has a heavy part of their budget allocated to brand terms and has a particularly good account quality score.

As new non-brand terms are added, their associated quality scores are often very good initially and then slump after a while – kind of like a honeymoon period.

My take on this is that Google uses the account's overall history until the keyword has had time to build up its very own history and then allocates more weighting to the keyword’s quality score rather than the overall account quality score.

Has anyone else had similar experiences?

Three Sure-Fire Steps every Search Marketer should take in Landing Page Optimisation - Step 3 Test, Measure, Refine & Improve

August 20th, 2007 by admin

Go test Ok you now have lots of tasty ingredients to make that killer landing page and you’re finally ready to go!

Its float or sink time, so sail that page into the unknown land of your customers’ persona, sit back and enjoy the ride.

The ride maybe fruitful and fun or insanely gloomy ““ it’s often a case of living’ ‘n’ learning, although destiny is firmly in your hands ““ you just have to reach out and grab it. The magic landing page formula comes to those who test, measure, refine and improve.

How to measure?

A great place to start is with the actual conversion rate for the page in reaching the desired action.

Lets’ look at the maths:

Conversion rate = (number of visitors who reach a desired action/total number of visitors) * 100

It surprises me that many companies do not know their own conversion rate for key pages that make up their conversion funnel or that there is such a lack of clarity as to whether an increase in sales has resulted from an increase in visitors or landing page enhancements.

A / B Testing

A/B testing is a simple an effective testing procedure that can be used in landing page optimisation in deducing which elements play a pivotal role in maximising conversion rates. You can test single variables such as a headlines, testimonials or images against each other in order to see the best performer.

A / B testing can be very effective over time, although it requires a variety of single variables to be tested in single file and can be quite time consuming.

You may like to checkout the Marketing Experiments explanation of A/B Testing for a more in depth look.

Multivariable Testing

Multivariable testing on the other hand allows for multiple variables to be tested in one go and a great example of this is through AdWords Website Optimizer. Again Marketing Experiments provide a detailed overview of this, which I highly recommend.

What about non-action pages?

Well not every page has an action that is as easy to measure such as a sale, registration or a specified next step. This is where a good analytics package comes in handy and Avinash describes four key metrics that are readily available in Google Analytics ““ Loyalty, Recency, Length of Visit & Depth of Visit. These metrics can give some real insight into how engaging a visitor finds your site and provide a useful tool in measuring landing page effectiveness.

In summary, as with many things related to online marketing you should assume nothing and test everything – the proof really is in the pudding! Decide what you want to measure and strive to improve.

Remember it’s your visitors’ actions and wants that really count and not necessarily what you think they want or worse still what your creative teams believes is in this season!
Step 1 Understand Your Visitors’ Persona
Step 2 Gain Permission and take the Visitor to the Next Desired Action

NMA's Search Agencies Guide 2007 (UK)

August 1st, 2007 by admin

NMA has complied a top 35 Search Agencies Guide for 2007. The guide has been out for a couple of months and allows me the opportunity to introduce Netizen (8th place) as my new place of work as a senior search executive. This is my first week and so far I am very impressed with the setup – checkout the top 10 below:

Three Sure-Fire Steps every Search Marketer should take in Landing Page Optimisation - Step 2 Gain Permission and take the Visitor to the Next Desired Action

July 26th, 2007 by admin

 diving chap Once you have an idea of the type of visitor persona (step 1) that will be landing on your site/page, you will then be in a good shape to decide what action you would like for them to take next and more importantly ensuring their needs are sufficiently satisfied.

The aim of marketing is to know and understand the customer so well the product or service fits him and sells itself Peter Drucker

This makes a lot of sense and follows on well, although for online marketing I think this quote needs to incorporate a well planned landing page to provide that extra nudge closer to the final goal :)

Let's start by looking at the 5 actions that can be caused by a landing page (Seth Godin):

    • Get a visitor to click (to go to another page, on your site or someone else’s)
    • Get a visitor to buy
    • Get a visitor to give permission for you to follow up (by email, phone, etc.). This includes registration of course.
    • Get a visitor to tell a friend
    • (and the more subtle) Get a visitor to learn something, which could even include posting a comment or giving you some sort of feedback

Ultimately you may want your visitor to do all 5, however your landing page as Seth describes should be optimised ideally for one and no more than two "“ otherwise things can start to become a little overwhelming and lack a clear call to action for the next desired step.

Optimisation of a stepping stone or path to conversion approach can often provide a preferred solution. It's important to define the desired conversion or better still, the conversion path to the desired end goal.

Fulfilling the Visitors' Needs & Your Own Marketing Goals

This requires not only a strong understanding for your visitors' persona, but also an appreciation of the stage in the buying process that the visitor/prospect is in.

If for example, a visitor is at the second stage of the buying process and is searching for information "“ then doesn't it make sense to provide this information and not a hard selling product page? Of course it does!

On top of this it can be a matter of seconds before your once curious visitor starts to get a little anxious and looks towards the back button "“ this is why it is particularly important to portray the page as being relevant, creditable and trustworthy:

Ensure Relevancy

  • The headline is perhaps the single most important part in ensuring relevancy and should reiterate the copy from the campaign source creative, whether it's from a PPC ad, an email ad or sometimes even the description in an SEO listing. From the research in step1, this should match their needs and the message should be continued in the body of the landing page.

Ensure Credibility & Trust

  • Is your company believable in its promise? Are there any obvious contradictions? Does it appear your site is deliberating hiding or making information hard to obtain? Is your company legitimate? Examples of factors that can reduce the buyer's trust anxieties are testimonials/case studies, assurances, guarantees, awards and credentials.
  • The contact and about-us pages are important too. The about-us page provides a great opportunity to install trust and sell what you are all about. Make sure that both pages are prominent and well written.

Once your visitor sticks around for a while, it's time to think about using your negotiation and persuasive skills to progress them on to the next stage.

Negotiation

  • Focusing on the benefits and not features of the products or services is a marketing classic, although so often forgotten. The title should offer a compelling benefit and/or promise and be backed up with a short opening paragraph.
  • Provide prospects with a feeling of relief by answering their biggest question, reservation, objection or misunderstanding early on.
  • List your Unique Selling Propositions (USPs) "“ what makes your product/service stand out from the crowd?
  • Unleash the power of emotion by connecting with prospects – it is often said that the fear of loss is greater than the desire for gain. Fear and jealousy are powerful emotions that can express a real feeling of loss or to have missed out on an opportunity. If the use of fear and jealousy are a bit much for you, there are plenty more to explore.

Guide Visitors to the Next Stage

  • A Clear call to action "“ e.g. an obvious big 'buy now' button or registration graphic should be shown above the fold.
  • Provide a careful balance of persuasive information and a lack of distractions. Distractions should decrease as the sales funnel deepens towards the end goal.
  • Ensure the best chance of getting your message read; landing pages should be scannable, with short sentences, engaging sub-headings and a modern look and feel that are also integrated with compelling images.

Of course, the buying process stage plays a big role in the exact implementation "“ and perhaps the most important step of all is to assume nothing and test everything:

Step 3: Test, Measure, Refine & Improve (arriving soon)

Three Sure-Fire Steps every Search Marketer should take in Landing Page Optimisation - Step 1 Understand Your Visitors' Persona

July 18th, 2007 by admin

 diving chapTargeted landing pages can be a great way in converting visitors into a pre-defined action. Persuasive on-page copywriting and page layout is a key part in landing page optimisation (LPO), although this alone is where many search marketers often run out of steam.

Use this opportunity to move ahead of your competitors with a simple three step approach:

1) Understand Your Visitors' Persona (off-page LPO)
2) Gain Permission and take Visitor to Next Desired Action (on-page LPO)
3) Test, Measure, Refine & Improve (off-page LPO)

Step 1 – Understand Your Visitors' Persona

This is the first landing page post in a series of three and concentrates on the understanding of your visitors' persona. This is a key piece of the jigsaw in defining the optimum user experience, customer journey and the most appropriate landing page.

Dave Chaffey provides a neat overview of web design personas and there is also an interesting seroundtable discussion on the subject.

Personas give a summary of the characteristics, needs, motivations and environment of typical web site users"¦

"¦A customer scenario (journey) is a set of tasks that a particular customer wants or needs to do in order to accomplish his or her desired outcome. Dave Chaffey

As a search marketer it is our job to identify the various types of visitor personas and their desired search journeys.

The Buying Decision Process

As part of the customer journey visitors are likely to pass through one or all of following buying decision processes:

  1. Want or Need recognition "“ prerequisite of further action;
  2. Search of information on products that could satisfy the needs of the buyer;
  3. Alternative selection "“ identification and evaluation;
  4. Decision-making on buying the product "“ choice made;
  5. Actual Purchase;
  6. Post-purchase behaviour.

Once you have a handle on the goals of your visitors, the customer journey and the buying decision process – you will be in a stronger position to concentrate on delivering relevant results to your visitors that are aligned to your marketing goals and will help in shaping the most optimal sales funnel.

For a textbook explanation of 'Understanding your Visitors/Customers', Adrian Palmer offers a free chapter Buyer's Behaviour and Relationship Development, kindly supplied by Oxford University Press.

Step 2: Gain Permission and take Visitor to Next Desired Action (arriving in the next couple of days)

PPC & SEO Services in the UK

June 30th, 2007 by admin

Last week, I had several interviews for some rather tasty PPC & SEO jobs in London, UK. It really does appear that the demand for skilled SEM employees is incredibly high at the moment. A common and unsurprising question often asked by recruiters and potential employers was to give a brief concise definition of SEO.

The simple answer that I gave is that it is the practise of optimising a web site both internally and externally to increase the volume of targeted traffic. With search engines especially looking at two key factors, results that are both relevant and popular to its users.

Relevance (on-page SEO) – the actual content on the page; this can be the text that a visitor can see and also the source code that search engines (& visitors) can read. The relevance of a page relates to the keyphrase that a user queries in a search engine and the search engine matching that with key elements on a page such as the title tag, header tags and the actual content of the page.

Popularity (off-page SEO) "“ every time another site references/links to your site, search engines perceive this as a vote that your site is important. The more links, the more votes "“ the more popularity search engines credit the site as having. The popularity increases every time your site acquires a new link, although not all links pass equal value (it depends on how much popularity/authority the linking web page has, as well as to how much relevance it has in relation to the page receiving the link).

Off-page SEO can also impact relevancy "“ with the keywords in the anchor text and surrounding area of the inbound link playing a major role.

Here is a very simple ranking formula:

Increased Relevance + Increased Popularity = Search Engine Trust + Higher Rankings

A more thorough ranking formula was discussed last year.

White Hat Vs Black Hat SEO

Another common question asked was to give my view on white & black hat SEO. This is a tricky question in an interview scenario "“ for those of you who are new to the terms white hate SEO is following practises that are accepted and encouraged by search engines, whereas black haters spam & manipulate the content (both on-page and off page) to achieve higher rankings.

Dave Chaffery notes that there are many shades of grey of SEO:

Its really about the combination of how proactive and how ethical you aim to be with SEO.

It can be very difficult to compete by being an 100% white hat SEO for very competitive keywords. You need to be aggressive and also appear natural in your link acquisition, but at the same time have a significant degree of ethical best practises.

In the 'shades of grey SEO' article I would not feel at all comfortable trying on hats 1 to 4, and explaining which hats I would try on in an interview scenario is not easy as many agencies perceive and publicise themselves as being 100% white hat – although I think most SEOs are neither one extreme or the other and fall somewhere in between. What colour hat are you?

Interesting SEM Posts You May Have Missed

June 16th, 2007 by admin

I am feeling a little guilty of late as I haven’t made many posts for a while, so I thought I would post an arrangement of links that you may find useful and have recently found their way on my bookmark list (not all new):